“I have always believed that the best way to move forward is to truly embrace our past.”
- Hon. John C. Crosbie, Lt. Governor and Patron of the Sealers Memorial Campaign
Talk of sealing and seal dinners always make me think of my late dad. He was from Wesleyville, a town that hardly needs to display its bona fides as far as sealing is concerned. Dad was born in 1917 and in the early 30’s he got his first berth on a sealing vessel in St. John’s. He would tell stories about his trips to the seal hunt. Once he fell through the ice and almost died. Dad came from a family of good cooks and knew a thing or two about cooking seal. I’ve always enjoyed eating it. My family roots in Newfoundland – on both sides – go back to the early 1700’s. Sometimes I think my appetite for seal meat is in my DNA. Am I part of a dying breed of seal eaters?
I raise the question because every year I go to a church basement or hall for a feed of flipper pie. Usually I’m one of the youngest people there – and I’m no spring chicken. Fewer and fewer folk go to these events. It’s also getting more difficult to procure seal meat. Last week I attended the Top Chefs Seal of Approval Dinner at Quidi Vidi Brewery in support of Home from the Sea, the Sealers Memorial Campaign for Elliston. There was no shortage of seal meat there and I came away convinced that with the right chefs, some smart marketing, and a bit of luck we could see people dining on seal in Newfoundland and Labrador restaurants.
Another era
Ironically there was a time in this province when people would eat seal before they’d eat lobster. My father’s generation saw lobster as something people ate when they were desperate. Lobsters were viewed as scavengers or garbage eaters – creatures that would consume literally anything. Seal meat was a delicacy in that era. In recent decades seal has become a tough sell. There’s labour involved in getting it ready for the pan or pot. It’s unusually dark and has a pungent aroma when cooking, especially if much seal fat is involved. My dad prepared seal meat very carefully, until it was free of all fat. Mind you, seal is not the only food that’s tricky to prepare. There are many. Ever try cooking sweetbreads? (That’s the thymus gland or pancreas of a calf.) I have.
The culinary team that initiated last week’s dinner wanted to accomplish two things. First they wanted to help raise money for the worthy cause of constructing a Sealers Memorial and Interpretation Centre in Elliston. But they also wanted to explore the culinary potential of seal, to experiment with the meat and determine which culinary techniques might be applied to it successfully. We happy diners were privileged to enjoy the results of their work.
First course was seal loin and pork terrine, created by Shaun Hussey and Michelle Leblanc of Chinched Bistro. Hussey makes lots of charcuterie – terrines and such – so I wasn’t surprised by the choice of dish. Nor was I surprised by the great marriage of flavours. Bacon seems to go well with everything, and combining pork fat with seal is quite traditional. Two rectangular slices of the terrine rested on a white plate. They were dark and flecked with pork fat. Pistachios here and there provided contrasting colour and texture. A little zip was added by a topping of mustard pickles.
Todd Perrin of Chef’s Inn prepared smoked seal carpaccio with spring salad. Fish and game take well to smoking and Perrin’s seal carpaccio was a perfect example. I liked the smoky edge that made the black truffle-like razor thin slices of flesh taste slightly more exotic. The seal carpaccio, like good caviar, sort of evaporated in the mouth. It was moRaymonds’ lto delizioso.
Seal ravioli
team of Jeremy Charles (absent for the actual event) and Kyumin Hahn came up with seal and veal cheek ravioli, and frenched rack of seal. A single, very plump raviolo cosied next to a beautifully frenched seal chop. The entire dish, including fabulous accents of salt roasted beet, butter radish and horseradish cream, was sensational. I was most impressed by the frenched seal chop. It was revelatory. Who knew seal could be made to look so sophisticated? Who knew seal could have such delicate texture? Who knew seal could be so succulent
A seal dinner celebrating the history of our sealers and sealing demanded a dish with echoes from our culinary past. Roary MacPherson of the Sheraton Hotel Newfoundland provided such a dish. I think most in attendance would agree his was the only dish influenced by traditional seal flipper pie. Still it was quite different. A beautiful stew of gravy, slowly braised seal meat and turned root vegetables was topped by a piece of fresh halibut en croute (in puff pastry.) At first I wasn’t sure about the introduction of halibut. I thought there might be a clash of flavours but both got along well.
Cynics may say the seal dinner was an attempt to romanticize the past, that most of us have no interest in dining on seal. Only an ignoramus could believe the people involved in the dinner and the memorial project are motivated by anything but a sincere desire to honour our history and sealers who lost their lives sealing – as well as exploring the culinary potential of seal. The meat of this wild game is extremely healthful. If talented chefs like Perrin, Charles, Hahn, Hussey, Leblanc and MacPherson can create palatable seal dishes with broad appeal that would be a very good thing. I believe all the dishes mentioned in this article could become consistent sellers in their restaurants.
Published in Weekend Telegram May 5, 2012




























